Buy The Ultimate Book of English Castles by Andrew J. Muller and Roy Barton


Peter Capaldi Title SequenceANDREW'S DOCTOR WHO REVIEWS
No. 257 - DARK WATER / DEATH IN HEAVEN


Story Broadcast: 1 November 2014 - 8 November 2014

Writer: Steven Moffat -  Director: Rachel Talalay

TARDIS Crew: The Twelfth Doctor - Clara Oswald




Dark Water / Death in Heaven

This is a story that, at the time, felt overly sentimental and too focussed on Danny Pink. However, now watching it a few years later on, it’s a strong and dark story. Yes, it does stray a little into over cloying particularly at the end, but there’s a lot to enjoy and central performances that are very strong. The double reveal at the end of the first part is also a great cliffhanger in the tradition of the Classic series as we meet up with the Cybermen once again and Missy is revealed as a female incarnation of the Master.

Whilst on the phone to Clara Danny is run over and killed by a hit and run driver. Clara is distraught and tries to force the Doctor to take her back in time to stop Danny being killed, instead he gets her to use the TARDIS’ telepathic circuits to take her to where Danny can be found.

They arrive in the 3W Institute and discover tanks with human skeletons sitting in the dark water that fills the tanks. They are greeted by Missy (Michelle Gomez) who says she is a welcome droid. A scientist, Dr Chang (Andrew Leung), tells them that the 3W was founded when radio signals discovered that the dead are aware when they are cremated, so their consciousness is transferred here and stored.

Danny has woken up in another part of the 3W Institute and is greeted by Seb (Chris Addison) who informs him of what has occurred. He is introduced to a child he accidentally shot whilst he was a soldier in Afghanistan and is given the choice to delete his emotions and memories. Clara phones him and he convinces her he is not really Danny to stop her trying to follow him.

Missy kills Dr Chang and then commands the skeletons in the dark water tanks to rise up. As the water drains away they are revealed as Cybermen. The Doctor runs outside and find that he is at St. Paul’s Cathedral. As the Cybermen emerge from hiding, Missy reveals herself to be the Master.

The Cybermen released by Missy fly into the sky and explode creating a ‘Cyber rain’ which hits graves where the dead are buried and brings them to life as Cybermen. Danny is also partially converted. Missy and the Doctor are taken prisoner by UNIT where the Doctor is inducted as president of Earth. Clara stalls the Cybermen at St. Paul’s by pretending to be the Doctor, she is rescued by Danny who retains his memories despite his conversion. She wakes up in a graveyard on the outskirts of London.

Aboard the UNIT airplane, Missy kills Osgood (Ingrid Oliver) and then throws Kate Stewart (Jemma Redgrave) from the airplane. Missy teleports to safety whilst the Doctor takes the TARDIS to the graveyard where Clara is. He tells her he can reveal Missy’s plans but cannot activate it without deleting Danny’s memories. At Danny’s behest Clara activates the device and he reveals a second rain will soon fall to convert the living into Cybermen.

Missy arrives and offers the Doctor control of the Cybermen, he refuses and offers it to Danny who takes the Cybermen into the sky and blows them all up, stopping Missy’s plans. Clara threatens to shoot Missy but the Doctor stops her, instead she is disintegrated by a Cyberman version of Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart who indicates where his daughter Kate has fallen having been rescued by the Cyber-Brigadier.

Danny has survived and contacts Clara from the 3W where he has brought the child he killed in Afghanistan back to life. They then say their goodbyes. Clara lies to the Doctor that Danny is actually still alive and he lies to her about planning to seek out Gallifrey which Missy has suggested has survived.

There’s masses going on here with Missy and the Cybermen and the whole plot around Danny and his demise. That particular plotline really comes as a surprise as it felt right up until the previous story that Clara and Danny are going to end up together and she will leave the Doctor. Whether that was a double-bluff on Steven Moffat’s part or – more likely – that Jenna Coleman changed her mind and decided to stay, it makes the death of Danny even more shocking.

Michelle Gomez as Missy is absolutely brilliant; she can do crazy so well and the scene on the UNIT plane where she is dancing around and calmly kills Osgood is both hilarious and chilling. She is the best Master since Roger Delgado and I look forward to seeing more of her soon. Chris Addison is great as Seb reflecting Missy’s funny but insane approach to the part.

There are some bits of the story that feel a bit OTT, for instance, where Clara keeps throwing TARDIS keys into a volcano, although the fact that this is a trick of the Doctor’s does take some of the craziness away from this, it still feels a bit of an extreme reaction on Clara’s part. Plus that last section in the graveyard does drag on a bit, attempting to turn the knife emotionally about Danny’s plight but it never really hits home and is just too long, and even in his Cyber-state Danny still can’t resist having a dig at the Doctor. Really, Danny? Leave it alone!

The Cyberman version of the Brigadier is both quite sad but also a bit silly and thankfully it was kept to a fairly small bit.

Otherwise there is a lot to like here. It’s darkly comic and has some disturbing moments and is a thrilling end of a patchy first season of Doctor Who for Peter Capaldi’s Twelfth Doctor.

NEXT UP:  LAST CHRISTMAS


© Text copyright - Raving Loony Productions and Andrew J. Müller, Roy Barton
and Shaun Runham
© Photos and Artwork - Andrew J. Müller
© Web Design and Layout - Andrew J. Müller
2022


Go to Home PagespaceGo to Andrew J. MullerspaceGo to Roy BartonspaceGo to Shaun RunhamspaceGo to Writing
Go to Castles of the UK and IrelandspaceGo to Castles of EuropespaceGo to Churches, Cathedrals, Abbeys etc.spaceGo to Travel PagesspaceGo to The Gallery