Buy The Ultimate Book of English Castles by Andrew J. Muller and Roy Barton


Peter Capaldi Title SequenceANDREW'S DOCTOR WHO REVIEWS
No. 259 - THE MAGICIAN'S APPRENTICE / THE WITCH'S FAMILIAR


Story Broadcast: 19 September 2015 - 26 September 2015

Writer: Steven Moffat -  Director: Hettie MacDonald

TARDIS Crew: The Twelfth Doctor - Clara Oswald




The Magician's Apprentice / The Witch's Familiar

This is a sort of mixed story really. There are some really great bits in it, but it also builds its plot around the Doctor being essentially tricked by Davros into giving up some of his regeneration energy which is a bit daft… if the Doctor doesn’t know not to trust Davros by this point then he never will. Having said that, we get more of Missy, and that improves any Doctor Who story!

The Doctor arrives on a battlefield and encounters a young boy (Joey Price) who is stuck amongst a minefield of “handmines”. The Doctor gives him his sonic screwdriver but when he learns the boy is called Davros. The Doctor then abandons him to his fate.

On present day Earth airplanes suddenly stop in mid-flight and UNIT contacts Clara, expecting her to bring the Doctor. Instead, it is Missy who contacts UNIT and insists on meeting Clara at an outdoor café. Here she reveals she has the Doctor’s “confession dial” which is the Time Lord equivalent of a last will and testament. They track the Doctor to 1138 where he has been partying in a very un-Doctorlike way. Before they can persuade him to go with them he is persuaded by Colony Sarff (Jami Reid-Quarrell) that Davros is dying and has asked the Doctor to come to him. With Clara and Missy in tow they arrive on a space station, the Doctor is taken to Davros but Missy and Clara discover it is not a space station at all, but Skaro, the Dalek homeworld.

The Daleks decide to kill Missy and Clara and destroy the TARDIS. The Doctor pleads with Davros to stop it, but he says he has no control over the Daleks and they fire. Back with the young boy Davros the Doctor raises a Dalek gun at him and says he will save his friends no matter what.

Missy and Clara are not dead, Missy has used a transmat device to take them outside the City, but it will only work once. They have to travel back into the City via a sewer. She then tricks Clara into going inside a Dalek casing as a disguise. Clara then finds she can only say “Exterminate” or “I am a Dalek”. Missy then abandons her.

The Doctor does not believe Clara is dead but is tricked by Davros into giving up some of his regeneration energy to save Davros’ life. However, the energy is channeled out to the Daleks who use it to rebuild themselves.

Missy comes to rescue the Doctor and kills Colony Sarff. They escape from Davros and encounter Clara, still stuck inside the Dalek, Missy tries to convince the Doctor that Clara is dead, but he sees through the ruse and rescues Clara after her Dalek asks for mercy. As they leave Missy is surrounded by Daleks.

The Doctor realises that the only way he worked out that it was Clara inside the Dalek was its concept of Mercy, so he travels back to Davros as a young boy and uses the Dalek gun to destroy the handmines. The boy asks what side the Doctor fights for, and he responds that it does not matter which side as long as there is mercy.

There’s so much to enjoy here, mostly in the performances of Capaldi, Julian Bleach as Davros, Michelle Gomez and Jenna Coleman. Despite this really being a story about Daleks and Davros, it is Missy who you remember the most as Michelle Gomez continues to build her version of the evil Time Lord into easily the best since the original.

Having said that, not a lot really happens in this story, the Doctor is tricked by Davros and people escape. That’s pretty much the lot, everything else is character and atmosphere, no bad thing but over a two-part story there is definitely room for more plot.

The handmines are really eerie and the topping and tailing of the story with the Doctor and the young Davros makes for a very satisfying conclusion.

All in all, a fair story, but not as spectacular as it deserves to be.

We also get the first time Peter Capaldi’s Doctor plays his electric guitar, a trick that would become a bit tiresome at times; and also the debut of the Doctor’s sonic sunglasses which are cooler.

NEXT UP:  UNDER THE LAKE / BEFORE THE FLOOD


© Text copyright - Raving Loony Productions and Andrew J. Müller, Roy Barton
and Shaun Runham
© Photos and Artwork - Andrew J. Müller
© Web Design and Layout - Andrew J. Müller
2022


Go to Home PagespaceGo to Andrew J. MullerspaceGo to Roy BartonspaceGo to Shaun RunhamspaceGo to Writing
Go to Castles of the UK and IrelandspaceGo to Castles of EuropespaceGo to Churches, Cathedrals, Abbeys etc.spaceGo to Travel PagesspaceGo to The Gallery